I think this discussion has been in existence ever since the “artificial” christmas tree came on the scene…”is it better to buy a real cut tree or should I buy a fake one”?

Now that we are in an era of counting our “carbon footprint”, wanting to be more “eco-conscious”, the  debate or should I say topic of discussion is even louder. I personally love the smell and feel of a real tree and I think most of us do too. However, a real tree has been planted, watered and fertilized for many years as it grows. Once it is ready to be harvested, they cut it down, spray it with a chemical to keep it fresh while it is being transported, sometimes across the nation and then be sold, watered some more and eventually thrown away or hopefully taken to a place that will shred it and turn it into mulch. This process doesn’t sound very eco-friendly to me, except that the tree farms are constantly replanting trees as they harvest mature ones which obviously keeps them in business.

Our next choice is purchasing an artificial tree, made from plastic, made in China, put into a box, shipped across the ocean, trucked to a store, sold to the consumer to keep and hopefully reuse for at least 10 plus years, if the owners take good care of it. The fake tree doesn’t require water and sometimes comes with it’s own lights already attached. Now they are using LED lights on the pre-ligthed trees, which makes them much more energy efficient. Of cousre, you do not get the “live tree” scent, unless you buy some in a can.

Our last option to note is purchasing a live tree which still has the root ball attached and can be planted outside after the holiday festivities are over and if it survives, you will then have a wonderful, permanent addition to your outdoor landscape. Of course, if you live in the desert southwest where Saguaro cactus is the norm, then you are out of luck. You could always ship it to a relative in the north country, but then there is that nasty carbon footprint of shipping something again. It can also be an issue if you live in a highrise condo and you do not have a yard to add more landscaping items, unless the local city park doesn’t mind you planting it on their turf.

So what to do, which way to go and is there a right or wrong choice? Each option has its positives and challenges. It truly depends on what each of us believes to be the right choice for our own circumstances. Over the years I have had cut trees and have planted live trees and now I own an artifical tree with LED lights already attached and I personally believe this is the best long term option for me, especially with the new environment I live in which is high desert and need to be very conservative with water.

So when you decide, let us know your thoughts and share your ideas for what you believe is the best Christmas tree choice for you!

Happy Holidays from EcoLita…who is the Ecodiva!